Shark PowerDetect Cordless Stick Vacuum vs Shark PowerDetect Speed Clean & Empty System

Quick take: The Shark PowerDetect Cordless Stick Vacuum costs $50 less; the Shark PowerDetect Cordless Stick Vacuum runs longer per charge (70 vs 60 min).

SpecShark PowerDetect Cordless Stick VacuumShark PowerDetect Speed Clean & Empty System
Price~$450~$500
TypeCordless StickCordless Stick
Suction——
Battery70 min60 min
Navigation——
FiltrationHEPAHEPA
CordlessYesYes
BaggedNoNo
Noise——
Dustbin0.7 qt0.5 qt
Water tank——
Self-empty dockNoYes
Auto mop washingNoNo
Hot water washingNoNo
Obstacle avoidanceNoNo
Carpet detectionNoNo
Auto mop liftingNoNo
Multi-floor mappingNoNo
App controlNoNo
Dimensions16.02 x 10.24 x 45.67 in—
Weight8.11 lbs14.2 lbs
Warranty5 years5 years

Pros & cons

Shark PowerDetect Cordless Stick Vacuum

  • ✓Rated 70 minutes in ECO mode
  • ✓0.7 qt dust cup is the larger of Shark's two PowerDetect stick bins
  • ✓HEPA filter on a dockless stick
  • ✓5-year warranty, matching the rest of the PowerDetect stick line
  • ✗8.11 lb is heavier than the 7.1 lb PowerDetect Speed
  • ✗No self-emptying dock in this version
  • ✗The 70-minute figure is an ECO-mode number; Shark gives no runtime for higher power settings
  • ✗No air-watt or noise rating published

Shark PowerDetect Speed Clean & Empty System

  • ✓Dock empties the dust cup without hand contact
  • ✓Same 60-minute runtime as the standalone IA1241
  • ✓HEPA filtration plus a 5-year warranty
  • ✓Converts to a hand vac for stairs and upholstery
  • ✓Nearest current replacement for the discontinued Detect Pro Auto-Empty System
  • ✗$70 premium over the dockless IA1241
  • ✗14.2 lb including the dock
  • ✗No suction, noise or dock-size figure published, so measure the space before buying