Dyson Ball Animal 3 Extra vs Shark PowerDetect Transformer Upright Vacuum

Quick take: The Shark PowerDetect Transformer Upright Vacuum costs $1 less.

SpecDyson Ball Animal 3 ExtraShark PowerDetect Transformer Upright Vacuum
Price~$531~$530
TypeUprightUpright
Suction290 AW1272 W
BatteryCordedCorded
Navigation——
FiltrationWhole-machine HEPA-sealedAnti-Allergen Complete Seal
CordlessNoNo
BaggedNoNo
Noise——
Dustbin1.7 L1.1 qt
Water tank——
Self-empty dockNoNo
Auto mop washingNoNo
Hot water washingNoNo
Obstacle avoidanceNoNo
Carpet detectionNoNo
Auto mop liftingNoNo
Multi-floor mappingNoNo
App controlNoNo
Dimensions15.5 x 11.0 x 42.2 in11.22 x 12.05 x 46.14 in
Weight17.3 lbs17.68 lbs
Warranty5 years5 years

Pros & cons

Dyson Ball Animal 3 Extra

  • ✓290AW corded motor never runs out of runtime mid-clean
  • ✓Self-righting Ball steering makes it easy to maneuver around furniture
  • ✓5-year warranty is longer than any cordless stick Dyson sells
  • ✓Tangle-free turbine tool and pet groom tool included instead of an extra purchase
  • ✓1.7L bin is large relative to Dyson's cordless stick bins
  • ✗Corded — 35 ft reach means outlet-hopping in bigger homes
  • ✗17.3 lbs is heavy to carry up and down stairs
  • ✗No battery/cordless convenience if that's what you're used to from Dyson's sticks
  • ✗Same core machine as the cheaper base Ball Animal 3 — you're paying extra purely for two tools

Shark PowerDetect Transformer Upright Vacuum

  • ✓Converts from upright to stick to handheld
  • ✓Corded, so runtime never limits a whole-house clean
  • ✓1.1 qt dust cup, larger than Shark's cordless stick cups
  • ✓Sealed-system Anti-Allergen Complete Seal
  • ✓30 ft power cord
  • ✓Same 5-year warranty Shark gives its cordless sticks
  • ✗17.68 lb is heavy to carry up stairs
  • ✗Power is given in watts, not air watts, so suction can't be compared directly
  • ✗$529.99 is high for a corded upright
  • ✗No noise rating published
  • ✗Pet tools cost extra, via the $649.99 TruePet bundle